I've smoked several pouches of the new MacBaren offering of Amphora. I smoked a fair amount of the Full Aroma back before it was removed from the market. The only blend my Granddad smoked was the Brown. To me, its the closest attempt yet. The cut seems different and the tobacco doesn't have the same feel that it used to. I would give it an 8 out of 10 rating of "exactness". It gets closer when you dry it out. IMHO.
Mike S.